#VATGate — Ireland's Agricultural VAT Fraud Scandal

The State is 1,000% Wrong — How Ireland's Government Enabled Agricultural VAT Fraud for Decades

A farmer identified a massive tax scam in 2013. He reported it to Revenue. Revenue agreed it was illegal. The Government was warned repeatedly. Over a decade later, the State is still defending the fraud in court — and the whistleblower has lost his livelihood.

This is the story of Alo Mohan, a Cavan chicken farmer and former chairperson of the National Poultry Committee of the Irish Farmers Association, who refused to participate in a VAT scam — and paid a devastating personal price for his honesty. The parallels with Ireland's banking fraud whistleblowers are impossible to ignore.

1,000%
VAT overclaim by some poultry farmers — Revenue's own 2017 figures
€20M+
Estimated cost to the State in recent years from poultry sector alone
€500M–€1B
Estimated annual cost to Irish taxpayers across all agricultural sectors
The Pattern is Familiar: A whistleblower identifies fraud. They report it through official channels. The State acknowledges the problem internally. The fraud continues. The whistleblower is destroyed. The media stays silent. Sound familiar? This is the same playbook used against Ireland's banking inquiry whistleblower. The same institutions. The same silence. The same consequences for the person who told the truth.
How the Fraud Works

Under EU law, no business can claim more in VAT than it pays. Ireland's flat-rate VAT scheme — designed to simplify VAT administration for small farmers — was exploited to generate massive overclaims. Here is the mechanism:

The fraud is perpetrated by select Processors who are authorised by the State to harness the Flat Rate Scheme. The Processor sells inputs such as Feed — which are zero-rated for VAT — to the Farmer, at an inflated price. For example, the price of feed sold by processors in the Chicken Sector is currently more than double the open market price. The inflated quantum of Flat Rate VAT which results is subsequently recovered from Revenue by the Processor. This is where the Fraud/Illegal State Aid occurs. — #VATGate Press Release, November 2024

Ireland's flat-rate scheme is uniquely exploitable compared to other EU countries:

  • No turnover threshold — Irish farmers turning over several million euros are not required to register for VAT (Germany caps at €600,000, France at €82,800)
  • Zero-rated inputs — Key inputs like animal feed and fertiliser are zero-rated in Ireland, yet farmers still receive a VAT refund on their sales as if they had paid VAT on those inputs
  • Higher flat-rate compensation — Ireland's flat rate was 5.6% until 2021, significantly higher than EU counterparts
Revenue's own figures confirm that in 2017, Irish poultry farmers over-claimed Flat Rate VAT by up to 1,000%. When Revenue ordered one practice to halt in August 2017, the overclaim dropped — from 1,000% to 750%.
Timeline — A Decade of Cover-Up
  • 2013
    Alo Mohan, Cavan chicken farmer, identifies the VAT scam and reports it to Revenue. His accountant Frank Lynch & Co advises that participating would amount to VAT fraud. A second opinion from former Revenue Commissioner Eugene Dolan confirms it is "a clear misuse/abuse of the VAT input credit regime." Despite refusing to participate on moral grounds, Mohan ultimately loses his business.
  • 2013
    Revenue is aware of the abuse. However, "a number of Revenue officials were unable to clarify for Mr Mohan if the schemes were illegal."
  • 2015
    Internal Revenue and Department of Finance records confirm the Government knew these practices were a likely breach of EU rules — described as "an anti-avoidance issue" and "against the spirit and purpose of the EU VAT directive."
  • 2016
    MEP Marian Harkin makes an official complaint to the EU's Director General for Finance about the practice.
  • 2017
    Ireland passes legislation giving the finance minister authority to exclude any agricultural sector from the flat-rate system if it abuses the rules. The EU closes its investigation, satisfied that Ireland now has the tools to act.
  • 2017
    Revenue's figures show 1,000% VAT overclaim in poultry sector. Revenue earned the poultry sector €7m more in that year alone — an average of €35,000 per farmer.
  • 2017
    European Commission instructs Alo Mohan to seek compensation from the Irish authorities.
  • 2019
    Revenue chairman Niall Cody admits before the Dáil spending watchdog: "There is no doubt that, within the poultry sector, the pricing structure allowed for an overcompensation of the VAT for some people who are in that trade." The solution: "To remove the flat-rate compensation for the sector." He confirms the minister has the report. Nothing happens.
  • 2019
    Former finance minister Paschal Donohoe writes to the attorney general: "There is significant overcompensation of unregistered farmers in the chicken production sector... This is unsustainable... overcompensation is not permitted under EU law." He asks for an exclusion order to be prepared — but never signs it after the Department of Agriculture becomes involved.
  • 2021
    Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín raises the "VAT fraud" and "illegal State aid" in the Dáil. Agriculture Minister Charlie McConalogue refuses to engage, saying it is not "appropriate" to raise the matter "on the floor of the House."
  • 2023
    Irish Mail on Sunday publishes a 9-page investigation — the only Irish media outlet to cover the story. Not a single other Irish news organisation reports it, reportedly due to a news blackout ordered by the Irish government.
  • 2024
    High Court case continues. Judge Emily Egan requests Garda investigate allegations that Revenue's legal representative Ms Juliana Quaney committed perjury. Mr Justice Owens refuses to release the Digital Audio Recording (DAR) from the February 2024 Discovery Hearing — raising GDPR and transparency concerns.
  • 2024
    #VATGate Press Release issued — 1 November 2024. Case continues. Justice has not been served.
Key Quotes from Official Records
"There is significant overcompensation of unregistered farmers in the chicken production sector. Despite Revenue's engagement with the sector, the practice continues. This is unsustainable in that the flat-rate scheme is designed to compensate unregistered farmers for the VAT paid on their inputs but overcompensation is not permitted under EU law." — Minister Paschal Donohoe, in correspondence to the Attorney General
"There is also a concern that the business model and contractual arrangements that have emerged in this sector could migrate to other agricultural sectors with potentially more serious implications for VAT revenues." — Minister Paschal Donohoe
"We have… presented a report to the Department of Finance; it is up to the Minister to act or not." — Senior Revenue official, internal correspondence
"Knowing as we do that nothing is likely to happen, what about putting our warning about the risks of the scheme migrating to other sectors on record?" — Senior Revenue official, frustrated at Government inaction
"Justice cannot be done in the dark. The refusal to release this recording denies me my basic right to access information that is crucial for my case." — Alo Mohan, on the refusal to release the DAR, October 2024
The Scale — Beyond Poultry

The fraud does not stop at chickens. According to the #VATGate press release, the State is also manipulating the Flat-Rate VAT Scheme to illegally provide state aid in beef and dairy sectors — with consequences for EU competition law and Irish taxpayers.

  • Fraudulent VAT claims and illegal state aid in poultry, pigs, beef and dairy could be costing Irish taxpayers €500 million to €1 billion annually
  • The broader VAT gap in Ireland, largely driven by fraud, amounts to €2.7 billion in lost VAT revenue annually
  • For European taxpayers, the cost of Ireland's favourable VAT schemes could be as high as €10–13 billion annually, distorting competition across the EU
  • The State has used its control over select processors to establish national brands — Bord Bia and Origin Green — enabling Irish processors to compete unfairly within the EU
  • Processing plants were divided into "Stayer" and "Goer" processors — inflated feed prices channelled VAT to "Stayer" processors while forcing "Goers" out of business. The strategic plan for the poultry sector aimed to reduce processing plants from 23 to 7. With the forced closure of Cappoquin Poultry in 2013, that goal was achieved.
Source Documents & Press Coverage
State Ignoring Farm VAT Scam Worth Millions
Irish Mail on Sunday — Michael O'Farrell, Investigations Editor — 4 June 2023 (front page)Download
State Ignoring VAT Chicken Fraud — Full Investigation
Irish Mail on Sunday — April 6, 2023 — 9-page investigationDownload
#VATGate Press Release — For Immediate Release
Alo Mohan & Raymond O'Hanlon — 1 November 2024. Ongoing High Court case: Alo Mohan vs. Revenue over fraudulent use of VAT as State Aid.Download
Correspondence to Michael McGrath — Finance Committee
Reporting the VAT fraud — response was to report to the GardaíComing Soon
Revenue Internal Review — VAT Overclaim in Poultry Sector
Never-before-published Revenue review seen by Irish Mail on Sunday — 2017Coming Soon
The Connections — Same Ireland, Same Pattern

The #VATGate scandal shares striking similarities with Ireland's banking fraud scandal documented throughout this site:

  • A whistleblower identifies fraud and reports it through official channels
  • The relevant authorities acknowledge the problem internally but take no action
  • The whistleblower loses their livelihood as a direct consequence of speaking out
  • The State uses public funds to defend the indefensible in court
  • A near-total media blackout prevents public awareness
  • Politicians are informed and do nothing
  • The courts' refusal to release the DAR mirrors the same court transparency issues documented on our Irish Courts page
Banking Expert — Why the Banking Inquiry Whistleblower Had to Be DestroyedLink
Irish Courts — Accessing Court Records & DAR RequestsLink
Retaliation — Official Ireland's Delay, Deny, Destroy StrategyLink

Questions or submissions? Contact@irelanddefrauded.com